This is just to keep up with what different colleges are doing about their Encampments, and this is College #1, Harvard (or, as we used to call it when I was a grad student, “Schmarvard”). A while back, to prevent Encampments, they closed Harvard Yard to all but those who could present a Harvard ID, and just to walk through or go to their dorm.
Nevertheless, the Yard got entented; by the second day, it looked like this (from the Harvard Crimson). That’s a lot of tents. Note the green and white jobbies, but here we also see blue and orange ones. The similarity of colors among tents bespeaks a common funder, but we don’t know who.
(from Crimson): The Harvard Yard encampment expanded as it entered its second day. Despite the Palestine Solidarity Committee heavily promoting the demonstration on social media, the group insisted that they did not organize the encampment. By Frank S. ZhouThe reason wasn’t divestment, but this:
The organizers behind a pro-Palestine encampment in Harvard Yard insisted that the demonstration was not organized by the Palestine Solidarity Committee, a clarification that protesters made amid heightened concerns about the potential for disciplinary action against the PSC and its individual members.
Instead, Harvard Out of Occupied Palestine — an unrecognized coalition of pro-Palestine student groups — is responsible for staging the encampment, according to organizers.
Students established the encampment to protest the College’s decision to suspend the PSC on Monday, after the group allegedly violated the terms of its one-month probation by organizing an unregistered protest on Friday that was co-sponsored by unrecognized student organizations.
According to an internal University document obtained by The Crimson, the PSC did not complete the terms of their probation, despite meeting with the Dean of Students Office multiple times to clarify the College’s policies around organized protests.
But the reason for this post is simply to show you how the interim president of Harvard, Alan Garber (replacing Claudine Gay until they find her successor), responded. He let the Encampent stay for 12 days and then issued the statement below:
The upshot, then, is that Harvard’s been remarkably tolerant of the encampment, despite activities (like the famous Keffiyeh Encirclement that I experienced) that are disruptive and distressing. Harvard wants to have its graduation, which is in the Yard, without the tents and their obstreperous inhabitants, and is announcing that the camp will be dismantled. Garber mentions the reason why all these encampments are illegal: while they can be partly seen as expressions of free speech, they violate the “TPM” requirements (“time, place, and manner”) that the courts have said can be part of free-speech policies on campus.
The gist of Garber giving the Encampment the pink slip is summarized in the last sentence, “Our disagreements are most effectively addressed through candid constructive dialogue, building not on disruption but on facts and reason.”
It’s a good letter, and Schmarvard has indulged its Encampers long enough.
Veritas! Will the University of Chicago have the spine to do what Harvard says it will do?
Oh, and a tweet:
BREAKING: Harvard protestors have expanded their encampment to a second lawn where commencement takes place and given the university a deadline of Monday to begin negotiations.
Shut. It. Down. pic.twitter.com/KISf0Nedt4
— Steve McGuire (@sfmcguire79) May 3, 2024